This review delves into the complexities and emotional weight of pet ownership, specifically examining the narrative presented in Jon Katz’s “A Dog Year.” The author expresses a profound sense of disappointment and feeling “ripped off” after reading the book, questioning the decision-making processes and emotional resonance of the author’s experiences with his dogs. This perspective is particularly relevant to individuals who have deeply considered or are currently navigating the responsibilities of caring for pets, highlighting the ethical considerations and emotional toll involved in such commitments.
The narrative begins with Katz’s affectionate portrayal of his two Labradors, emphasizing their seemingly idyllic life together. This is soon juxtaposed with the introduction of Devon, a troubled border collie from a breeder friend, whom Katz reluctantly adopts. This decision point is where the reviewer’s discomfort begins, drawing a parallel to their own internal struggles when encountering adoptable animals, ultimately choosing not to adopt due to existing resource limitations and commitments to their current pets. The reviewer posits that adopting a pet is akin to a lifelong commitment, akin to marriage or having a child, requiring a steadfast dedication through all circumstances.
Katz’s subsequent focus shifts heavily to his struggles with Devon, overshadowing his initial fondness for his Labradors. The reviewer notes Katz’s wife’s apparent reluctance to fully engage in his dog-centric life. A significant point of contention arises with the illness of one of the Labradors. The reviewer, having personal experience with end-of-life decisions for a pet, criticizes Katz’s immediate decision to euthanize the dog without thoroughly exploring treatment options. Furthermore, the reviewer expresses anger over the perceived lack of time given to the dog to adjust to a less active life, arguing that the dog should have had an opportunity to “retire” with dignity rather than being put to sleep as soon as its activity level decreased.
The narrative continues with the breeder pressuring Katz for a puppy, leading to another contentious decision. Despite his and his wife’s reservations, Katz acquires a new puppy, influenced by a recommendation from Oprah Winfrey during a promotional appearance. The reviewer finds this decision-making process particularly egregious, questioning the validity of basing such a significant commitment on an off-the-cuff remark made by someone unfamiliar with the specific situation, especially when the motivation cited is simply to “make himself happy.” This lack of responsible deliberation left the reviewer feeling unwell.
Further research by the reviewer revealed that “A Dog Year” has a seemingly happy ending, yet Katz later authored a book detailing his decision to euthanize Devon due to behavioral issues. This information solidifies the reviewer’s distrust in Katz’s judgment as a pet owner. The reviewer points to specific examples, such as encouraging Devon to chase trucks, even from behind a fence, as questionable practices. Ultimately, the reviewer concludes that there is little to be gained from Katz’s perspective, as his expressed love for his dogs lacks a resonant connection for the reader, who is left with a desire to find a more vulnerable animal in need of care.